MazdaSpeed 3 Round 2
So, University Mazda was happy to let me drive the MS3 on the highway today. Tracks really well even on that grated pavement they’ve got going on up there. Goes like a little rocket. Yes some torque steer, but at the speed/accel I was driving it it was totally manageable. Really very fun. It’s kinda loud at idle. Too loud for my taste. But, I think that’s probably a minor thing. Still pretty much love it. Have to be ok with pretty bad gas mileage and a higher insurance rate. Very fun car.
Hyundai Sonata Limited 2.0T Round 2
Got this on the highway today as well. Even with three people in it, it was rocket-fast. Unfortunately, on the highway the steering wanders a bit. This class of car should not require a ton of attention to keep it going straight, but it does. The tiny Speed 3 is way more planted. As much as I like the Sonata, I think that aspect pretty much kills it for me. I drive too much on the highway to have to fight it all the time. On this round I also noticed the engine is kinda growly, noise-wise. It doesn’t really sing like a honda engine does. Just not a very satisfying sound. The six speed automatic transmission, while it does a good job in first gear, tends to shift a *lot* when just driving around. A little annoying. Build quality and the general feeling of quality in it also dropped for me on my second look at it. The materials just feel kinda paper thin. Sadly, I think this car is out of the running.
Subaru WRX
Awesome Charles let me drive his new WRX up and down the lake today, too. It’s performance profile felt pretty similar to the Mazdaspeed 3, but the delivery was very different. Much more controlled and buttoned down, but still totally sick-fast. A hearty exhaust note at idle but not nearly as much as the 3. It has that characteristic Subaru engine sound too, which is cool, but I think the Mazdaspeed engine spins up a little freer, and the low-rpm torque in the 3 felt stronger. I would prefer a 5 speed like in the WRX to a 6 speed like in the 3, but I think the 3′s shifter works a bit smoother. After the drive I noticed I was wearing my stupid Keen shoes, too, which screw up driving a stick quite a bit. Maybe because of that I felt a little clumsy in the WRX compared to the 3, but I’m not sure which contributed more, or maybe I was just trying to be too nice to the car since it isn’t mine and if I really hammered it things would go smoother. I prefer the look of the WRX to the 3. The 3 smiley-face grille is annoying (though much better on the Speed than the normal one), and the back is a bit meh for me, while the WRX front and back are both chiseled and nice. Interior materials were a nut-hair nicer in the 3 I think. Both were a step below Honda grade, and a step above the Hyundai. Mirror and window visibility was a bit better in the WRX than the 3, but both were OK (and neither were as good as my Civic or Odyssey). The WRX interior is *very* mellow (almost spartan) compared to the 3′s raft of buttons everywhere.
Now I have to decide if 20mpg average when I commute 40 miles/day is acceptable (works out to about $800/year in fuel cost over a 30mpg average car). Insurance will be $400/year higher on a MS3 or WRX than a non-sports car also. But… it’d also mean I have to go find something else that I haven’t considered yet (or re-consider the fuel-efficient (but I think it’s too slow (even though it is a bit peppy) and I don’t like the raspy-sounding engine and swoopy wheels) Skyactive Mazda 3). There’s the regular 2.5L Mazda 3 @ 167hp, which Car and Driver seems to like, but… it’s only 21/28 fuel economy… That’s really not much better than the 19/25 the Mazdaspeed3 gets with 93 more HP. Another thing to factor in is that a car would have to be *very* fuel efficient for me to hit 30mpg in it (basically only that Skyactiv 3 has the right combo of a bit of power and extreme fuel efficiency to make it worth it). Otherwise I’m down in the 25mpg zone, and 20mpg vs 25mpg is getting less significant. I’m pretty sure I get around 25mpg in my Civic cuz it has to be utterly flogged to keep up with traffic, and the cursed 5th gear in it is so short it spins 5000rpm at 65mph.
More food for thought. Hmmmm….